The surcharge alone is rarely the reason to sell. It is a reason to run the numbers before the first bill arrives in January. If you were already weighing a sale, a new annual cost can settle the question.
What the Surcharge Is
New York City now charges an annual surcharge on certain homes that are not a primary residence. The law took effect on July 1, 2026. The charge is a percentage of the market value set by the Department of Finance.
It sits on top of the regular property tax. It is not a transfer tax, and it is not owed only at a sale. It returns every year the apartment stays a second home.
Who Pays and How Much
The Department of Finance publishes these rates for condos and co-ops. They cover the tax years that began July 1, 2026 and July 1, 2027.
- Valued at $1 million or more, but less than $3 million: 4 percent
- Valued at $3 million or more, but less than $5 million: 5.25 percent
- Valued at $5 million or more: 6.5 percent
Townhouses and other one to three family homes valued above $5 million pay 0.8 to 1.3 percent.
The rate applies to the full value, not only the amount over a threshold. A co-op the city values at $2 million would owe $80,000 a year at the published rate. You can read the rules on the Department of Finance surcharge page.
The City’s Value Is Not Your Sale Price
The surcharge uses the Department of Finance market value, not what a buyer would pay. For condos and co-ops, that figure is usually far below the sale price.
The Department of Finance compares a co-op it values at $1 million with a house valued at $5 million. In practice, the surcharge reaches apartments that sell for roughly $5 million and up.
The Department of Finance published a supplemental roll in July 2026 that lists these values. Appearing on the roll does not mean you owe the surcharge. In a co-op, the tax bill goes to the building. Ask your managing agent how the surcharge will reach you.
The published rates cover two tax years. The law changes how condos and co-ops are valued after that. Ask your tax advisor what your later years look like. The Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY) offers a tool to check whether the surcharge applies.
Who Is Exempt
The surcharge does not apply when the home is the primary residence of one of these people:
- The owner
- A tenant or subtenant
- An immediate family member of the owner
- The majority owner of a company that holds the property, or the beneficiary of a trust
The deadline to apply for an exemption for this tax year was October 13, 2026. The first charges appear on the property tax bill due January 1, 2027. Owners who disagree with the city’s value can appeal to the New York City Tax Commission.
Three Choices for a Second Home Owner
Keep it and pay
If you use the apartment often and the cost is acceptable, nothing has to change.
Rent it to a full time tenant
A tenant who lives there as a primary residence can qualify the apartment for the exemption. The owner has to prove it with the lease and the tenant’s records. Many co-ops limit subletting, so check your building’s rules first.
Sell
A sale ends the annual cost. It makes the most sense for owners who use the apartment a few weeks a year.
What the Surcharge Is Doing to Prices
Buyers of second homes now count the surcharge in their offers. An apartment that most buyers would use as a pied a terre carries a cost that older sales did not.
I told Haven Lifestyles in September that the surcharge could prompt some owners to sell sooner than planned. After I explained the surcharge in a short video, more than 30 owners reached out with questions.
An apartment that works as a primary home still draws its full pool of buyers. Pricing has to start with who the likely buyer is. I cover the broader picture on my pied a terre tax page.
If You Decide to Sell
Timing matters. The first bill is due January 1, 2027, and the surcharge returns each year. An owner who lists in January can be in contract by spring. I explain the calendar in list in January or wait for spring.
Price against what a buyer will owe to hold the apartment. Do not price against sales from before July 2026. My guide to how to price a Manhattan apartment correctly explains the method.
Know your net number before you decide. My guide to what it costs to sell a co-op in Manhattan covers transfer taxes, the flip tax, and fees.
How I Help Second Home Owners Decide
- I confirm how the city values the apartment and whether a notice was sent.
- I ask how often you use the apartment and what holding it now costs each year.
- I check the building’s sublet policy, in case renting is an option.
- I price the apartment for both likely buyers, the full time resident and the second home buyer.
- I prepare a net proceeds estimate, so you can compare selling with holding.
My NYC seller’s agent page explains how I price and market a listing.
I am not a CPA or an attorney, and this article is not tax or legal advice. Confirm your own exposure with your tax advisor and your attorney.
I’m Caroline Bass, a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker and the founder of The Bass Team at Corcoran. I hold the New York Residential Specialist (NYRS) designation from the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY). I have closed over $400 million in career sales since 2005. The Bass Team was named Corcoran’s West Side Sales Team of the Year in 2019, 2020, and 2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who has to pay the NYC pied a terre surcharge?
Owners of certain New York City homes that are not a primary residence. For condos and co-ops, it applies at a Department of Finance value of $1 million or more.
How much is the pied a terre surcharge on a condo or co-op?
For the first two tax years, the rate is 4, 5.25, or 6.5 percent of the Department of Finance market value. The rate depends on the value tier.
Is the surcharge based on my purchase price or my sale price?
No. It is based on the market value the Department of Finance assigns. For condos and co-ops, that value is usually well below the sale price.
Does renting out the apartment remove the surcharge?
It can, if the tenant lives there as a primary residence and the owner documents it. Check your building’s sublet rules before you rely on this.
What happens to the surcharge when I sell?
The surcharge is an annual charge billed with property taxes. Ask your attorney how any unpaid amount is handled at your closing.
Contact Caroline Bass to discuss pricing, timing, and strategy.
