Before you sign with a Manhattan buyer’s agent, ask four things. Ask about their co-op board record, the buildings they know, how they are paid, and what the agreement requires. The answers should be specific. An agent who cannot name buildings and boards is not ready to represent you here.
Why the Choice Matters More in Manhattan
Most Manhattan listings are represented by the seller’s agent. A buyer’s agent represents you, not the apartment.
Much of the Upper West Side and Upper East Side is co-op. Your agent has to know which boards will approve your finances before you make an offer. A mistake there costs months.
Eight Questions to Ask
How many co-op purchases have you closed in the last two years?
Ask where they were. Board experience in your target neighborhoods matters more than total volume.
Which buildings fit my financial profile?
A prepared agent asks about your assets and income first. The agent then narrows the list to buildings whose standards you meet. My guide to post-closing liquidity explains the main test.
Has a board ever turned down one of your buyers?
A direct answer is a good sign. Ask what the agent learned and what changed afterward.
How do you prepare a board package?
The agent should describe a checklist, a calendar, and a full review before submission. See what goes in a Manhattan co-op board package for the standard.
How are you compensated, and who pays?
Compensation is discussed more openly than it was a few years ago. The seller may offer it, or you may pay it under your agreement. Get the terms in writing before you tour.
What does the buyer representation agreement commit me to?
Read the term, the neighborhoods it covers, and whether it is exclusive. Ask how either side can end it. New York also requires agents to give you a disclosure form that states whom they represent.
How do you find apartments beyond the public listings?
Some sales never reach the listing sites. Ask how the agent hears about them.
Who will I work with day to day?
On some teams the person you interview is not the person who shows you apartments. Ask for names.
Red Flags
- The agent cannot name specific buildings or boards
- The agent promises that a board will approve you
- You are asked to sign before the terms are explained
- The answer about compensation is vague
No agent can promise a board decision. An agent can only prepare you for it.
A Realistic Timeline for a Spring Purchase
Buyers who want to close in the spring should choose an agent in November or December. Touring in January and February leads to a contract in February or March.
Board review and closing take two to three months after that. My guide to how long NYC co-op board approval takes lays out each stage.
If You Are Also Selling
Many buyers on the Upper West Side and Upper East Side own an apartment they need to sell. Ask whether the agent can coordinate both transactions.
The sale usually sets the budget and the calendar for the purchase. My NYC seller’s agent page covers that side.
How I Work With Buyers
- I review your finances before we tour, so every building on the list is one you can pass.
- I explain each building’s board culture, maintenance, and rules before you make an offer.
- I prepare the board package with you and review it before it is submitted.
- I stay with the transaction through the interview and the closing.
My NYC buyer’s agent page describes the process in more detail. Past clients share their experience on my testimonials page.
I’m Caroline Bass, a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker and the founder of The Bass Team at Corcoran. I hold the New York Residential Specialist (NYRS) designation from the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY). I have closed over $400 million in career sales since 2005. The Bass Team was named Corcoran’s West Side Sales Team of the Year in 2019, 2020, and 2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a buyer’s agent in NYC?
Yes. Most NYC listings are represented by the seller’s agent. A buyer’s agent represents you, not the apartment.
Who pays the buyer’s agent in NYC?
It depends on the transaction. The seller may offer compensation, or the buyer may pay under the representation agreement. Confirm the terms in writing before you tour.
How many buyer’s agents should I interview?
Two or three is enough to compare experience and approach. Ask each one the same questions so the answers are easy to compare.
When should I hire a buyer’s agent for a spring purchase?
Choose an agent in November or December. That leaves January and February for touring and a contract by early spring.
Contact Caroline Bass to discuss pricing, timing, and strategy.
